PyInstaller False Positive: Windows Defender Flags App as Trojan

by

What will you learn?

You will learn how to tackle the issue of Windows Defender mistakenly identifying an application created with PyInstaller as a trojan.

Introduction to the Problem and Solution

When utilizing PyInstaller to convert Python scripts into standalone executables, it’s common for antivirus programs like Windows Defender to flag the resulting executable as a false positive for being a trojan. This can occur due to the packaging process of PyInstaller, which might trigger heuristic detection algorithms in antivirus software.

To resolve this issue, adjustments need to be made in the PyInstaller configuration. It may also involve excluding specific files or directories that are triggering false positives in Windows Defender.

Code

# Include this snippet in your PyInstaller spec file before running `pyinstaller` command.
a = Analysis(['your_script.py'],
             pathex=['path_to_your_script_directory'],
             binaries=[],
             datas=[],
             hiddenimports=[],
             hookspath=[],
             runtime_hooks=[])

pyz = PYZ(a.pure)
exe = EXE(pyz,
          a.scripts,
          exclude_binaries=True,
          name='output_executable_name',
          debug=False,
          strip=False,
          upx=True,
          console=True )

coll = COLLECT(exe,
               Tree('path_to_additional_files'),
               a.binaries,
               a.zipfiles,
               a.datas + [('excluded_file_path', 'destination_path')],
               strip=False,
               upx=True)

# Copyright PHD

If you haven’t created a spec file yet, you can generate one by executing:

pyi-makespec your_script.py

# Copyright PHD

This will create a .spec file that you can then modify using the provided snippet.

Note: Ensure to replace placeholders like ‘your_script.py’, ‘path_to_your_script_directory’, etc., with relevant values for your project.

For more advanced configuration options and detailed packaging process fine-tuning, refer to PythonHelpDesk.com and check out the PyInstaller documentation.

Explanation

  • Analysis Object: Contains essential information about what should be included in the final packaged executable.
  • PYZ Object: Merges all pure-Python modules into one archive.
  • EXE Object: Specifies settings for creating the final executable.
  • COLLECT Object: Gathers all necessary components (including additional files) for distributing the application effectively.

By configuring these objects correctly within your PyInstaller spec file, you can optimize how your application is bundled and potentially avoid triggering false positive detections by antivirus software like Windows Defender.

    How do I determine if my app is falsely detected by Windows Defender?

    Windows Defender typically displays alerts or quarantines suspected files. Check its history log for further details.

    Can excluding specific files help prevent false positives?

    Yes, excluding certain resources or directories during packaging can often resolve false positive detections.

    Is modifying the PyInstaller spec file complex?

    While it requires some understanding of PyInstaller workings, following documentation should assist you effectively.

    Should I always apply these configurations even if no issues arise?

    It’s advisable because proactive measures could prevent future problems with various antivirus programs too.

    Conclusion

    Addressing false positive detections from antivirus software such as Windows Defender when utilizing applications packaged with tools like PyInstaller involves adjusting packaging configurations. By adhering to best practices in setting up exclusion rules and optimizing package bundling methods, developers can ensure their applications are not erroneously flagged during security scans.

    Leave a Comment