Why Does Mypy Raise an Error When a Subtype is Returned with TypeVar?

What will you learn?

  • Understand why mypy raises an error when returning a subtype with TypeVar.
  • Learn how to resolve this issue and ensure type correctness in Python.

Introduction to the Problem and Solution

In Python, using TypeVar for defining generic types allows flexibility in creating functions or classes that can work with various specific types. However, if mypy detects an issue where a subtype is being returned instead of exactly matching the specified type hint with TypeVar, it signifies a problem with type consistency that needs attention. To address this, it’s crucial to align function signatures correctly with the defined type hints.


from typing import TypeVar

T = TypeVar('T', int, float)

def example_func(arg: T) -> T:
    return arg * 2

result_int = example_func(5)
result_float = example_func(3.14)

# This would raise an error as we are trying to return a float (subtype) instead of the expected int input
result_error = example_func(10)

# Copyright PHD

Credit: PythonHelpDesk.com


When utilizing TypeVar to define generic functions like example_func(arg: T) -> T, we specify that the function takes an argument of type T and returns a value of the same type T. If mypy identifies a return of a subtype rather than precisely matching the specified type hint, it raises an error due to violating the expected contract set by our type annotations.

To overcome this issue, it’s essential to ensure strict adherence of our functions to their defined signatures. Modifying the implementation as shown below resolves the problem:

def example_func(arg: int) -> int:
    return arg * 2

# Copyright PHD

By clarifying and aligning function definitions with their intended types, we enhance code readability and maintainability while leveraging Python’s static typing benefits through tools like mypy.

    1. Why does mypy complain about returning subtypes?

      • Mypy enforces strict static typing rules; hence any deviation from specified types triggers warnings or errors during checking.
    2. Can I ignore these complaints from mypy?

      • While possible using annotations like # type: ignore, it’s generally discouraged as it defeats the purpose of utilizing static typing benefits.
    3. What is TypeVar used for in Python?

      • TypeVar allows defining placeholder types for generics so that functions/classes can seamlessly work across multiple specific types.
    4. How do I specify multiple acceptable types for TypeVars?

      • By passing additional types as arguments within TypeVar, separated by commas like (T1, T2).
    5. Is static typing mandatory in Python?

      • No, static typing is optional but highly recommended for improving code quality especially in larger projects or teams.
    6. How does dynamic vs. static typing differ in managing data integrity?

      • Dynamic typing checks variable values at runtime whereas Static checks variable data before running them causing fewer errors.
    7. What happens if I violate defined typings?

      • Violating defined typings could lead to unexpected behavior where variables might not behave accordingly leading to runtime bugs.
    8. Can you explain how isinstance() works?

      • The isinstance() method checks if given object belongs o particular class or not.
    9. Does correcting these issues affect runtime behavior?

      • Addressing these issues primarily helps catch potential bugs early during development through static analysis tools like mypy without affecting runtime performance directly.
    10. Are there other alternatives to TypeVars for generic programming in Python?

      • Yes, concepts like abstract base classes (ABCs) also support generic programming approaches besides using TypeVars explicitly.

In conclusion,… Additional information… Final thoughts…

Leave a Comment